Pender, Nebraska
Pender, the county seat of Thurston County, was founded in 1885 on land within the Omaha Tribe's reservation that had been opened to outside settlers the year before; in 2016 the U.S. Supreme Court confirmed that the town still lies within the reservation's boundaries. About 140 of our relatives lived there, from the town's first years into the 1930s.
Omaha and Winnebago homelands
Every acre of Thurston County lies within two Native nations' reservations, the Omaha in the south and the Winnebago in the north, a shared history the county itself describes as unique. This was Omaha country. In a treaty signed in Washington on March 16, 1854, the tribe, in hard circumstances, gave up most of its land west of the Missouri and kept a reservation of 300,000 acres. The tribe chose the land around the Blackbird Hills. The powerful Omaha leader Blackbird, remembered in the area's old informal name of Blackbird County, died in a smallpox epidemic around 1800, and tradition holds that he was buried seated on his horse on the hilltop near present-day Decatur where he used to watch for traders.
The Winnebago, or Ho-Chunk, came here as refugees. After being moved again and again from Wisconsin through Iowa and Minnesota, they were forced out of Minnesota in 1863 in the turmoil after the Dakota War of 1862 and sent up the Missouri to Crow Creek in Dakota Territory. Close to 700 of them died there between 1863 and 1865. Some escaped downriver in canoes to the Omaha, who took them in. In a treaty of March 6, 1865, the Omaha agreed to sell the northern part of their reservation to the United States so that it could become a home for the Winnebago, and the two nations have been neighbors ever since.
Allotment and the opening of the land
In the years that followed, Congress passed laws to sell parts of the Omaha reservation. An act of 1872 offered land on the western side of the reservation for sale, but only about 300 acres sold. Then, after the tribe granted the Sioux City and Nebraska Railroad a right of way through the reservation in 1880, an act of August 7, 1882, which the anthropologist Alice Fletcher had lobbied for, divided much of the reservation into individual allotments for tribal members and allowed land west of the railroad to be sold to outsiders. Fletcher herself oversaw the allotments, and the Omaha act became a model for the national Dawes Act of 1887. Under its terms, outsiders could buy up to 160 acres at no less than $2.50 an acre, and in April 1884 the government declared 50,157 acres west of the railroad open for settlement.
It is important to remember what this meant from the Omaha side. The tribe had said in the 1870s that it wished to sell part of its western land, but it was Congress and the Interior Department that set the terms of the 1882 sale, and over the following decades many tribal members also lost allotted land to outsiders, especially after a 1916 law let Thurston County tax the allotments and families fell behind on the taxes. The settler families who came to Pender, ours among them, arrived as part of that larger story.
Athens becomes Pender
The first village in the newly opened land was Athens, started in 1885. Its buildings were soon moved about two miles northwest to the new townsite of Pender. The town was named for Sir John Pender, a Scottish businessman famous for the transatlantic telegraph cable and a director of the railroad. One of the first settlers on the site, S. M. Young, went into the livery business and later served as sheriff. The census of 1890 counted 429 people, and by 1900 there were 943.
The county was organized in 1889. Lawmakers had tried in 1887 to name it Blackbird County, after the Omaha leader, but the governor vetoed the bill, and it was named instead for U.S. Senator John M. Thurston of Nebraska. Pender has been the county seat from the start, though not without a fight. In the early 1900s Walthill tried to take the seat away, challenging Pender in court and circulating petitions, until Pender supporters showed that signatures had been gathered fraudulently. In 1927 the county turned an 1895 school building into a permanent courthouse, which helped settle the matter.
Whose land? Nebraska v. Parker
For more than a century Pender was generally treated as if the 1882 sale had taken it out of the reservation. Few Omaha people lived west of the railroad after the early 1900s, and in 1999 a Nebraska state court placed the reservation boundary at the railroad right of way east of town. The Omaha Tribe disagreed, holding that only Congress can change a boundary set by treaty. In 2006 the tribe began requiring liquor sellers on the reservation, including those in Pender, to buy licenses and pay a tribal sales tax, and Pender merchants and the village went to court.
The case reached the U.S. Supreme Court. On March 22, 2016, in Nebraska v. Parker, the justices ruled unanimously, in an opinion by Justice Clarence Thomas, that the 1882 act had opened land for sale without shrinking the reservation, so that "the disputed land is within the reservation's boundaries." Pender, most of whose residents are not members of the tribe, thus sits within the Omaha Reservation, a reminder that the history of the town and the history of the tribe cannot be separated.
Our family in Pender
Our records hold 140 relatives connected with Pender, beginning in 1883, around the time the land was being opened, with most of the entries falling in the 1930s. The surnames that appear most often include Frey, McQuistan, Witt, Slaughter, Gilster, Murray, Parker, Eichler and Luhr. The town they knew grew from 943 people in 1900 to 1,006 in 1930 and 1,135 in 1940, a farm market and county seat on the railroad, with the Omaha and Winnebago communities of Walthill, Macy and Winnebago nearby. The 2020 census counted 1,115 people.
Timeline
- 1854 Omaha treaty of March 16 sets aside a 300,000-acre reservation
- 1863 Winnebago forced from Minnesota to Crow Creek
- 1865 Omaha agree to sell the north part of their reservation for the Winnebago (treaty of March 6)
- 1880 Omaha grant a right of way to the Sioux City and Nebraska Railroad
- 1882 Act of August 7 provides for Omaha allotments and sale of land west of the railroad
- 1884 Land west of the railroad opened to settlers (April)
- 1885 Athens started; its buildings moved to the new townsite of Pender
- 1889 Thurston County organized, with Pender as county seat
- 1916 Law lets Thurston County tax Omaha allotments
- 1927 Former school converted into the Thurston County Courthouse
- 2016 Supreme Court rules in Nebraska v. Parker that Pender is within the Omaha Reservation (March 22)
The family in Pender
The family records have 140 people who were born, lived, married, died or were buried here. These are the earliest of those who have passed away. Their pages are in the members’ section; you will be asked to sign in.
- Statira Kathryn Sinclair born 1883
- Tillie Olga Swanson born 1884, died 1957
- Katie Altie Frey buried 1885, born 1885, died 1885
- Charles Justin Sinclair born 1886
- Ruby L. Sinclair born 1886
- Estella Matilda Frey born 1889, lived 1930, lived 1940
- Pearl Vesta Cressy born 1889
- Edward I. Frey died 1890
- Gustave August Rudolph Witt born 1890
- Christian Henry Witt born 1892
- Ivan Eugene Frey born 1892
- Mabel Beulah Lund born 1893, lived 1930, lived 1940
- Henry C. Krieger born 1894, died 1970
- Effie Olive Frey born 1895
- Emma Wilhelmina Louise Witt born 1895
- Edward Clarence Frey born 1896
- Frank Earl Parker born 1896
- Heinrich H. Suhr born 1897, died 1979, buried
- Eva Parker born 1898
- Fern Frey born 1899
- Harry Dietrich Luhr died 1899
- Harry C. Seastone born 1900
- Wiebke Kathrina Muehlert died 1901, buried
- Ferdenand Eichler died 1902
- Peter Jacob Witt buried 1902, died 1902
- Daisy Mae Baker born 1906, lived 1920, lived 1930
- John A. Robbe died 1907
- Lloyd Arthur Slaughter born 1908, buried 1985
- John Comfort McQuistan born 1909, buried 1957
- Sophie Focht died 1909
- Velma L. Frey born 1909, died 1909
- Alton Frey born 1910
- Anna Sophia Kramer lived 1910, buried 1915
- Charles Gottlieb Ottman lived 1910
- Edward Frey lived 1910, buried 1923
- Elizabeth Allsworth lived 1910
- Martha Jane MacNeil died 1910, buried
- Paul Wallace Murray born 1910, lived 1920, lived 1930
- Charles Henry Hartwig died 1911, buried 1911
- Pearl S. Frey born 1911, died 1912
- Russel Leroy Slaughter born 1911, died 1970
- Frances Viola McGuire born 1912, died 2001
- Charles Harvey Frey buried 1913, died 1913
- Matilda Augusta Eichler buried 1913
- Ervin Eugene Frey born 1914, died 1994
- Richard Eichler died 1914
- Alton Charles Slaughter born 1916
- Deloy Fred Kratke born 1917, died 1983
- Donald McQuistan died 1917, buried
- Joacim H. Test buried 1918
- Marjorie June Gilster born 1919, baptized 1920, died 2014
- Claus Jacob Witt lived 1920, lived 1930, died 1941
- Emma Louise Wilhelmina Test lived 1920, lived 1930, died 1934
- Edna Mae Krusemark born 1921
- Gertrude Faye McQuistan born 1921
- Mary Holmes died 1922, buried 1922
- Lauren Sophia Sebade born 1923, died 2004
- Albert Richard Rastede died 1924
- Donald Dean Krieger born 1924
- Leon Lee Slaughter born 1924
… and 78 more.
See also
- Atkinson, Nebraska
- Boyd County, Nebraska
- Bristow, Nebraska
- Butte, Nebraska
- Coleridge, Nebraska
- Creighton, Nebraska
- Gross, Nebraska
- Hartington, Nebraska
- Holt County, Nebraska
- Inman, Nebraska
- Lynch, Nebraska
- Monowi, Nebraska
- Niobrara, Nebraska
- Norfolk, Nebraska
- O'Neill, Nebraska
- Pierce, Nebraska
- Plainview, Nebraska
- Spencer, Nebraska
- Verdigre, Nebraska
- West Point, Nebraska
Sources
- Pender, Nebraska (Wikipedia, starting point and census table)
- Nebraska v. Parker, 577 U.S. 481 (2016), opinion (Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School)
- Omaha Reservation (Wikipedia)
- Winnebago Tribe of Nebraska (Wikipedia)
- Nebraska: Winnebago Reservation (Partnership With Native Americans)
- When Little Hill met the Umoⁿhoⁿ (KWIT Small Wonders, 2023)
- About Our County (Thurston County, Nebraska official site)
- Thurston County, Nebraska (Wikipedia)
- Thurston County Courthouse (Nebraska) (Wikipedia)
- First Thurston County Courthouse (Wikipedia)
- Semi-Centennial History of Nebraska (1904): Thurston County officials (NEGenWeb Project)